Home Grown
Thrillers and True Crime Saga
Fascinating, when they don’t involve you
By Cynthia Adams
The detective’s office wasted nothing on aesthetics. Beige blinds, desks stacked with folders. A diploma from somewhere on the wall. Stiff chairs faced his desk, where we perched awkwardly as the detective sank into a swivel chair.
Forget the trench coat. Who expected “dad” clothes — a short-sleeved shirt and shorts? He was folksy. Affable.
“Sara” sat wide-eyed beside me as the detective presented a stack of papers, part of a background investigation of a much younger woman involved with her ailing brother.
Like everyone with a streaming subscription, I’d watched scammer sagas. The detective thumbing through a fat file seemed scripted. Yet this was personal, lives laid bare. The work often done for lawyers, which is how Sara found hers.
Investigating deadbeat dads, cheating spouses. Insurance fraudsters. Grifters.
The detective began reading, pausing as Sara gasped.
“Sonya” — the focus of this investigation — maintained multiple identities in various states. Her date and place of birth was apparently fluid; Sonya was 34, 36, 37 or 38 and had six different email accounts.
A phone number was the sole consistency.
Her record included DUIs, open-carry charges, reckless driving, speeding. Drug possession. Fake IDs.
Many serious charges were dropped.
“Despite the fact that she uses fake driver’s licenses?” asked Sara.
The detective nodded. “And an expensive lawyer.”
Two hours later, we had a slippery grasp as to who Sonya actually was.
Since meeting in a bar, Sonya occasionally lived with Sara’s brother, “Ralph,” who was decades older. He claimed it was platonic.
Sara had spent the last two years helping her brother survive cancer treatments. Cleaning his home. Buying his food. Sonya was seldom seen. By happenstance, Sara learned he had recently changed his will, leaving Sonya everything.
She had come to me for solace and advice. “I believe he loves her,” she choked out.
Sonya was comparatively young; her brother, though frail, was stubbornly obsessed.
Deaths had decimated Sara’s prosperous family. Now there was only her and Ralph, her remaining brother. Sonya, too, had brothers.
The detective produced snapshots of Sonya’s siblings. One, with The Illustrated Man tattoos covering face and body, had a criminal record. The other, sometimes bearded and masculine, was also photographed cleanly shaved and dressed as a woman. Wait, was that actually Sonya? Was he a doppelganger?
Fabrications and aliases underscored their criminality.
“It could be very serious. When I see a background report like this, it often points to drugs. And the things that . . .” the detective paused . . . “go with that.”
Were Sonya or her brothers coercing Ralph?
They could be dangerous to challenge, the detective warned. Our eyes fell upon the thick file.
“And, you know, I tend to think your brother already knows who she is.”
Sara’s face crumpled.
The detective seemed downcast — apologetic for being the bearer of bad news. Everywhere around the world, similar stories unfolded. Sonya’s was an old story, the detective had said tiredly, closing the folder. In Netflix dramas, there’s some closure at the finale. In real life, seldom.
Outside the sun was beating down, but the humidity had dropped, suggesting summer’s grip was loosening. We slid into Ralph’s luxury sedan, which he had urged Sara to use.
“Keep it,” he had said.
“I’ll give it to Sonya,” Sara said now quietly, turning the ignition. “I think I’m going to stop the investigation. The detective is right.”
We drove through streets dappled with golden light. Sara dropped me off, her hand fluttering goodbye as we turned away in tandem.
A leaf blower, the main instrument in our urban soundtrack, moved towards a crescendo as a neighbor tidied up the detritus at their door. OH
Cynthia Adams is a contributing editor to O.Henry magazine. Email her at inklyadams@aol.com.










